There is a lesson to be learned from falling sports stars, it's just not very clear what that might be. There has been a concentrated string of sports heroes that are paying for indiscretions or evacuating their role as king of the mountain, and yet the moral lesson is still ambiguous. If we are going to make examples of athletes and coaches that make bad choices, then it should be clear why they are examples. Although sports figures are paying a heftier price than they once did, are they (or we) becoming better people because of it?
Baseball got the ball rolling by exposing the steroid issue. We have watched certain Hall of Famers sit in front of cameras and admit to steroid use in tearful apologies. We have watched with much more discomfort as the last of the steroid players vehemently denied their use, and decided to go down with the ship.
Then we have the "in between" guy Mark McGwire who finally came out of the steroid closet to ease his transition back to baseball. Rather than a straight forward apology, we got McGwire the victim, the rationalizer, and the delusional. There was an apology sandwiched in there somewhere. A wise man once said, "apologies under the gun are overrated."
My avid readers will remember I predicted an apology from McGwire as being unnecessary [The Punishment Fits the Crime: Big Mac's Return to Baseball] (this is becoming a habit), because it wouldn't change any opinions or shed any light on what was going on while he played. It is just a forced interaction that the media demands. It fits more in the category of celebrity gossip than watchdog journalism.
On a side note: If you want to see a reporter on top of his game, check out Bob Ley of ESPN's Outside the Lines. He has a wonderful blend of serious questioning and human decency. He is one of the few reporters that I admire in journalism, and I always feel like his work is for the public, and not for career advancement by being provocative. Sensationalism and spotty ethical framework are the driving reasons I decided not to pursue a career in the field. After watching Ley's latest series of interviews with McGwire, I feel a change of heart. He gives me faith that journalism can be an honorable profession. You just have to go to sports reporters to find it. What a shame...
Sports heroes have become more of a target these days. There's Tiger Woods (enough said), Mark Mangino, Mike Leach, Jim Leavitt, Michael Vick, Gilbert Arenas, Marvin Harrison, etc. I realize these cases are not related (other than the football coaches), but the days when sports figures literally got away with murder are over (thanks OJ). The Plaxico Burress conviction reversed the idea that professional athletes get favorable treatment from the courts by making him an example of tough gun control law.
The next to fall off the mountain could be former University of Southern California head coach Pete Carroll. Carroll decided to leave USC to become the head coach of the Seattle Seahawks. There is nothing too strange about Carroll's desire to give the NFL another crack, but the way the change took place seemed quite odd. Carroll made some statements eluding that the college atmosphere could not live up to the NFL's, and in a flash, he was gone.
To Seattle.
Not exactly the dream situation you would think Carroll would leave USC for. After inhabiting what most around college football viewed as the top position for nine seasons, Carroll jumped ship seemingly out of nowhere.
Shortly after, reports began swirling about NCAA infractions by the USC football program. Carroll has coached with impunity in his tenure with USC. No other program in the nation had such egregious dealings ignored by the NCAA. How long has the entire nation known that Reggie Bush's family was given a home? People have gone on record with proof that these transactions took place, yet no action has been taken.
Conversely, there are universities that find out about violations of the program, kick the players responsible off the team (including the starting QB), self impose scholarship restrictions, and the NCAA still hammers them. The largest biases in collegiate athletics does not live in the media, it resides in the justice league that is the NCAA. They clearly have programs they hate, and programs they adore. The NCAA has long been the Gestapo of the sports world, but for some reason USC remained immune during Carroll's tenure. It must be his moon reflecting smile.
Regardless of the past, it seems like USC has gotten away with too much and the NCAA must finally take action. They have already buried their basketball program for being dirty, and it looks like football is next. The Bush issue has resurfaced along with allegations that RB Joe McKnight was driving around LA in an SUV purchased by a booster for his "girlfriend."
The only reason I have any confidence in the NCAA to exact their brand of justice is due to Carroll's fleeing. He had the cushiest job in college athletics serving as football king in LA, a city that Carroll seemed perfectly suited for. Instead, he leaves the sun and beach behind for the tropical paradise of Seattle. How do you take your Latte, Mr. Carroll? Hope you packed your slicker.
College coaches have a history of fleeing programs that are about to be punished. The university takes the hit and the coach walks away to another job. Anybody ever heard of Kelvin Sampson? It looks like Carroll will be the next on that list. How can the NCAA let this happen? They are the strictest governing body in all of sports, yet they allow coaches to escape unharmed for their violations.
With the money paid to college basketball and football coaches, it is time to start hitting them in the wallet. I'm so sick of seeing the guys responsible for violations slink away in the night, only to watch the innocent schools and fans live with the punishment. As former Tennessee and current USC head coach Lane Kiffin highlighted, college coaches are really just free agents that follow the dollar. They don't have to live up to contracts, they don't have to follow rules, and they don't have to suffer the consequences of their actions.
College coaches are the only ones getting paid (legitimately), yet there is never a financial punishment. Why?
I understand that punishing the university is part of the process. It should be. But if they are not going to suspend coaches, then the NCAA should be fining them. Sports is used to teach life lessons and the NCAA acts as the moral authority. Coaches are directly responsible for imparting these lessons to their student athletes. What kind of life lesson are we teaching by letting coaches act without consequences?
Carroll will leave a legend in USC folklore while the program suffers consequences that are long overdue. Don't get me wrong, I don't feel bad for USC at all. In fact, I think they are going to get what they deserve with Kiffin as their new head coach. Tennessee is currently being investigated for several minor infractions Kiffin left behind. When the money and temptation of LA gets in his blood, there will inevitably be repercussions. I don't think the media will give Kiffin the pass Carroll had.
An unfortunate precedent has been set with the current system, and it is up to some competent people in the NCAA to reverse it. I realize "competent NCAA" is an oxymoron, but I can hope. Until the coaches themselves are punished for fleeing violations, there will be no change in their dirty activities. It is my belief that nearly every major program is dirty within the confines of NCAA restrictions. Either start paying the players or fining the coaches. The current system is faulty, and we will see just how much when they rule on USC.
So what have we learned from all these sports heroes? Men cry more often than we thought? Don't get caught? Money rules everything? I guess the answer is yes.
None of our baseball heroes caught in the steroid scandal would have admitted to cheating unless they had already been caught. None of our "old school" college football coaches would have been fired if they got along with their athletic directors. Tiger Woods wouldn't be losing sponsors if he wasn't such a colossal star that transcends sports. NBA and NFL stars would still be getting slapped on the wrist if it wasn't for the public outcry for serious litigation against rich athletes.
In the end, we do not have a better understanding of right and wrong from this latest public lashing. If the ends justify the means, then the most valuable lessons in athletics have been lost. The greatest teaching tool of human character is obscured by fame, greed, ego, and a faulty system of justice. If the NCAA truly wants to keep athletics pure, then they need to clean their own house. When they do, they can bury USC in the pile of skeletons they will need to shed to illustrate a clear ethical picture.
